
How do you negotiate with famously aggressive negotiators like Donald Trump?
That is the question people around the world are asking themselves.
For example, Forbes contributor Andrew Cave writes in a recent post that Britain urgently needs skilled negotiators to deal with tough negotiators like the new President. Britain is not alone. Anyone with business before the US government must be wondering how to cope given Trump and his senior advisors’ reputation for hard bargaining. And since a presidency can shape the tone of an era, we may see more aggressive negotiating elsewhere too.
The question of how to deal with tough counterparts isn’t a political one; it’s a practical one. Even Democrats like Chuck Schumer and Elizabeth Warren say they are willing to work with President Trump when they can.
The question is how. Knowing how to negotiate with a tough counterpart doesn’t necessarily mean defeating him or her; it may actually help both sides.
In fact, studies find skilled negotiators can create ‘good for you, very good for me’ deals. In contrast, weak negotiators may cost both sides value. Surprisingly, one study suggests mutual loss is more likely when one side is famously tough; when novices encounter experts who have highly aggressive reputations, novices can become so defensive that both sides often wind up doing worse. Regardless, negotiating skill can help you win. It can also let you know when it really is wise to walk away – and when it isn’t.
So how do you actually negotiate with someone who’s known for being a hard-bargainer? Counterintuitively, it’s not about bluff, bluster, naively responding in kind, or giving in. What does count is how well you prepare.
First, preparation sometimes reveals that a supposedly intimidating counterpart isn’t that effective. Many of Donald Trump’s business deals turned out to be bad for him. Preparation may help you discover your fears are exaggerated. But, what if your counterpart really does use intimidating methods effectively?
Here are three ways to improve your odds:
1. Know the interests, options, and facts. It’s natural to think negotiating is all about making demands. They do matter a lot. But naively focusing only on demands can cause you to miss creative opportunities for both sides—opportunities you can discover if you know the underlying needs and creative options that can meet them.
The Camp David peace talks, for example, hinged on doing just that; it worked even though Egypt’s Sadat and Israel’s Begin were so hostile they couldn’t be in the same room. Mastering the facts and figures can help you find these creative options better, and can give you more credibility, power, and discernment at the table too. It can also help you set specific, evidence-based targets – a must when dealing with hard bargainers.
2. Make moves away from the table. When you feel weak, it helps to do things away from the talks that strengthen your position at the talks. That first means developing your best alternative to a negotiated agreement – the thing you’ll do if you can’t agree.
For example, the governor of the tiny island nation of Malta once avoided British pressure to cut Britain’s navy base leasing fees, eventually tripling those fees. How? By signaling Malta’s interest in offering the base to Britain’s Cold War adversary Russia.
Another effective move away from the table: finding powerful allies. On November 23, 1963 new President Lyndon Johnson learned a key looming vote in the Senate would likely go against him and cripple his presidency. Knowing Senators zealously prized their power and wouldn’t listen to him, Johnson found others they would listen to – their states’ governors. Appealing for the governors’ support the night of John Kennedy’s funeral, Johnson convinced them to press their Senators, which won Johnson overwhelming support when the vote was held.
3. Roleplay. Research shows that roleplaying can help negotiators prepare more effectively for the emotional and cognitive challenges they’ll face. The experience is much like the way top athletes visualize their performances, and Presidential candidates roleplay for debates.
In brief, while the lead negotiator prepares, a teammate prepares as if she were the aggressive counterpart. They meet in character and negotiate for a few minutes, debrief, negotiate, debrief, and so on. The better the teammate understands and aggressively plays the real-life counterpart (including his personality, tactics, and psychological tendencies), the more valuable the experience. In contrast, President John Kennedy reported his 1961 encounter with Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev was the most harrowing experience of his life because Khrushchev used intimidation tactics Kennedy was ill-prepared for. Kennedy hadn’t roleplayed to ready himself.
The good news is that you don’t need to sell your soul or give up the store to negotiate effectively with aggressive negotiators. Though the experience can be stressful, negotiators who prepare well have a much better chance of reaching outcomes that serve them – and perhaps the other side – well.